Superior Pizza enjoying Main Street location

| November 17, 2014

DSC_0062COSHOCTON – Larry Caudy, owner of Superior Pizza, is pretty pleased with his new location.

“We do five times a day better here than we ever did,” he said.

Superior Pizza opened on Oct. 10 at 611 Main St. It had previously been located on Second Street, where it opened on Feb. 28.

“We needed dine-in,” Caudy said. “We had no space for that there and I also wanted to bring in a buffet.”

His new location has room for 72 people and a buffet full of salad, spaghetti, breadsticks and 12-14 different pizzas. Caudy also plans to eventually add soup to the buffet.

The move also allowed Caudy to expand his regular menu. Since moving, he’s added pastas, specialty calzones, specialty pizzas, can turn any sub (except the steak one) into a pizza and also offers burger and fries.

“I’m very, very happy here,” Caudy said. “I love to cook and love to prepare food.”

He started in the pizza business seven years ago in Lewis Center and is glad he finally landed on Main Street in Coshocton.

“I’m renting right now, but I hope to buy this building,” Caudy said. “It’s 4,000 square feet and has a basement that I’d love to turn into a game and pool room eventually.”

For the time being, customers can enjoy their favorite games on one of the restaurants five televisions.

“It’s a great place to hang out and watch your favorite game while eating great food,” Caudy said.

There doesn’t seem to be one menu item that is most popular with the public, but he does get a lot of good feedback about the fresh deep fried wings and their 11 different sauces, calzones and garlic parmesan fries and the Cajun ones. Caudy also is working on some pulled pork menu items.

“I like to mix things up and am always changing,” he said.

Superior Pizza also offers carryout and delivery. Orders can be placed by calling 575-3036.

“I’m glad to be on Main and hope I bring more foot traffic to the other people here,” Caudy said.

He’s also interesting in learning the history of his building and would like to get some old pictures of it to hang up inside.

“I would love to see Main Street go back to the way I heard it was,” Caudy said.

[email protected]

Tags: ,

Category: Uncategorized

About the Author ()

I started my journalism career in 2002 with a daily newspaper chain. After various stops with them, I am happy to be back home! I graduated from Coshocton High School in 1998 and received a Bachelor of Arts in Communication in 2002 from Walsh University. I also earned several awards while working for daily papers, including being honored by Coshocton County’s veterans for the stories I wrote about them. I am honored and ready to once again shine a positive light on Coshocton County. I also am the proud mother of a little girl named Sophia!

Comments are closed.